It was a huge anniversary year, celebrating the uniting of many states into one nation. It was a divisive year, full of brutal oppression by peacekeeping forces against a captive public, massive extraction of wealth from the working class by the elites who rule the capitol, and the aging President was hyperfocused on his personal grudges, destroying lackeys who failed him and directing state power against citizens who dared disrespect him. It was the United States' 250th Anniversary. It was the 2nd Quarter Quell, and Panem met its worst victor, Haymitch Abernathy. Previously played by Woody Harrelson (True Detective, Indecent Proposal), The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping mints a new star in Joseph Zada (East of Eden, Invisible Boys) as his younger self. In fact, there are many such younger selves at play as The Hunger Games franchise looks back on itself with the retrospection of middle-age, not just depicting what came before, but reexamining the future with world-weariness. This latest entry is meaner but not leaner, and able to stand as one of the best entries in The Hunger Games.
The novel The Sunrise on the Reaping (2025) was the best book of the series, and a political statement from author Suzanne Collins,. Her two prequel books to the original trilogy are even more determined to beat the reader over the head with subtext about policing, class, and fascism, lest a stupid reader not get the point. As a consequence, the book this film is based on is the darkest, saddest, and most violent. So too with the film, though it does pull a select few punches to avoid both an R rating, and potential controversy.

Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. Photo Credit: Murray Close
“I didn’t expect to see you until after the reaping”
Despite the unfortunate changes, director Francis Lawerence (The Long Walk, The Hunger Games: Catching Fire), Director of Photography Jo Willems (The Hunger Games: Catching Fire, Finch), Production Designer Uli Hanisch (Queen's Gambit, Cloud Atlas), and Costume Designer Bina Daigeler (Tár, Mother Mary) deliver the best looking film in the franchise, and among the best looking Blockbuster IP films of the last few years. All of these department heads contribute to this, but Daigeler's costumes in particular are a gorgeous achievement in sci-fi storytelling. Utilizing shapes from 1970's fashion could easily have come across as a cute gimmick, but instead, the result is a visual culture that feels like several different designers being influenced by the 70's at the same time. This grounded fictional fad creates the feeling of a 60's and 70's cultural revolution that never was, stifled by President Snow's control. Even the lead's performance feels like a lead performance of yesteryear, dressed in his patched clothes and righteous anger.
Making a prequel is hard. Making a second one is even harder. A sidequel, a middlequel, a cashgrabquel, any film pinned between two known, fixed points in time will struggle to find a new dramatic engine to rev that doesn't contradict its boundaries. Joseph Zada's performance threads the needle by beginning in a classical gear, playing Haymitch like the younger version of golden age actors like Rock Hudson in All That Heaven Allows (1955). Once in the arena, his performance becomes more and more modern in its internality. But he is not alone in this. All of the cast of this 12th district of yesteryear speak in a Southern-Appalachian accent more at place in mid-century recordings than the Tennessee of today. The dialogue too evokes a more classical poetry than previous films, nodded to as the influence of Edgar Allan Poe through spoken tradition. The best deliveries of this dialogue belong to Mckenna Grace (Gifted, Slanted) whose flinty performance proves her mettle as a young adult actor, expanding her range. She is tough, funny, and compelling as Masyliee Donner, the stand-out role from the book. If only the film's pacing had allowed her the same benefit of time as the page did.
While the film may start with patient pans across the 12th District at dawn, it takes off running in clipped fashion before the first exchange of dialogue is over. For the first act of the film, very little of the dialogue shots have any handles on the side of them, no room to breathe. But not breathless with anticipation; breathless like an asthmatic on the third flight of stairs. It's an understandable decision as the film already runs an overwhelming 2 hours 39 minutes, and the first act is where to do it, letting the hurried nature of The Reapings' events carry you through the choppy waters so that the most important moments in Act 2 and 3 can breathe beautifully. But the best of Mckenna Grace's role is in that rushed third, and she's worse for it.

Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbess and Joseph Zada as Haymith Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. Photo Credit: Murray Close/Lionsgate
“Best Ally Ever”
But she isn't the only standout performance in a supporting role. Ralph Fiennes (The Grand Budapest Hotel, 28 Years Later) is excellent as the middle ground between Tom Blythe and Donald Sutherland's President Snow. Elle Fanning's (Sentimental Value, The Neon Demon) performance as a young Effie Trinket, previously played by Elizabeth Banks, is electric, and Jesse Plemons (Game Night, Civil War) does Philip Seymour Hoffman proud as Plutarch Heavensbee. His is the best performance in the film, playing a double agent whose real feelings are legible only to the audience in the briefest flutters of the eye lid. Kelvin Harrison Jr. (Cyrano, Alpha Gang) also successfully fills the shoes of a screen icon as Beetee, previously played by Jeffery Wright. In fact, you have to go deep down the list to find a poor performance in this film, a testament to both the casting and directing. This is premium Hollywood filmmaking.
More than the other films, this entry explores what it means to live under the games, and oppression, for generations. The dialogue is classical, but also more pointed than previous films. The characters debate the generational struggle for freedom, but they are also children, and more than any other film in the franchise, it makes you see them as such. They are naive, self-conscious, scared, and small, like many viewers were when they saw the first film on a childhood midnight at the movies, watching Rue die.
When adapting a text, the author of the adaptation can realign the thematic threads with their own sensibilities. The book is brutally cynical in its depiction of The Fight for freedom, but it has a bittersweet, minor thread of hope from knowing how the story ends. In this adaptation, through direction and specifically the performance of Plemons, this becomes a major key in the work, asking the audience to imagine a better world is possible. It works, because it's also a better movie than many of the studio films released this year.
Final Score: 4/5
Generative AI: ?
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping releases on Thursday, November 19th, 2026. For more information, visit HungerGames.movie
Free, private email, now with 60% off premium this Black Friday.
A private inbox doesn’t have to come with a price tag—or a catch. Proton Mail’s free plan gives you the privacy and security you expect, without selling your data or showing you ads.
Built by scientists and privacy advocates, Proton Mail uses end-to-end encryption to keep your conversations secure. No scanning. No targeting. No creepy promotions.
With Proton, you’re not the product — you’re in control.
Start for free, or upgrade for 60% off this Black Friday. Stay private always.

